The Age of Trump : In the struggle for the soul of the West, it’s Bannon vs. Merkel

  • -Aktualisiert am

If Bannon is basically a Christian (or Social) Democrat on economics and an anti-Muslim conspiracy theorist like Frank Gaffney on the question of Islam, he’s a Pat Buchanan-esque paleoconservative when it comes to national identity. His hostility to immigration stems from a belief that non-Western immigrants are largely incapable of assimilation; it was Bannon who was allegedly the brains behind Trump’s disastrous Executive Order temporarily prohibiting citizens from seven Muslim-majority countries from entering the United States. In his Vatican speech, Bannon spoke favorably of “a global tea party movement” whose European affiliates include the United Kingdom Independence Party and France’s National Front (and, presumably, the Alternative for Germany, Poland’s Law & Justice and Hungary's Fidesz, all of which have received fawning coverage from Breitbart). Acknowledging how some of these movements have “baggage, both ethnically and racially,” Bannon ultimately wishes them success because “strong countries and strong nationalist movements in countries make strong neighbors.” This, of course, runs counter to everything that a conscientious and historically-aware German Chancellor like Angela Merkel has come to believe, as must Bannon’s chilling, post-election promise, uttered to the Hollywood Reporter, that, “We’re just going to throw it up against the wall and see if it sticks. It will be as exciting as the 1930s.”

Merkel is, perhaps to a fault, bloodlessly pragmatic. Rare does she implement sweeping, dramatic policy changes.
Merkel is, perhaps to a fault, bloodlessly pragmatic. Rare does she implement sweeping, dramatic policy changes. : Bild: AFP

Finally, Bannon and Merkel differ profoundly in their visions of Europe. The Chancellor, who grew up in communist East Germany, innately understands Vladimir Putin’s Russia as a threat to Western values and security. Fending off complaints from both her left (Greece’s Syriza-led government) and right (Hungary’s Viktor Orban), she has held the line on the European Union sanctions regime imposed upon Moscow for its territorial annexation of Crimea and ongoing invasion of Ukraine, which she termed as exemplifying “the law of the jungle.” Bannon, meanwhile, like Trump, sees Russia as a potential ally in the fight against Islamic terrorism as well as a bulwark in defense of traditional values; both Bannon and Putin support the same, illiberal populists currently on the rise across Europe. “The Judeo-Christian West really have to look at what he’s talking about as far as traditionalism goes — particularly the sense of where it supports the underpinnings of nationalism — and I happen to think that the individual sovereignty of a country is a good thing and a strong thing,” he said of Putin in 2014. Whereas Merkel stresses the importance of NATO as the bedrock of Western security and a deterrence against Russian revanchism, Bannon, also like his boss, appears to view the alliance as a nuisance. According to the New Yorker, Bannon recently asked the National Security Council staff to compile a list of contributions that each member state has made to the alliance since its 1949 founding, a peculiar obsession of the president he serves and a question “designed to impugn NATO’s legitimacy.”

Trump's indifferent, if not openly hostile to the European project

With federal elections approaching this fall, it’s not only Russian meddling that should concern Merkel, but American as well. Trump has made clear that he’s at best indifferent, if not openly hostile to the modern European project, and Bannon has indicated that anti-E.U. populists have a friend in the White House. is said to be opening a Berlin bureau later this year (and has tried to hire, I am told, writers from Tichy’s Einblick) a development that could radically alter German journalism for the worse by injecting into public discourse the sort of crude, conspiratorial xenophobia that, by law and custom, the postwar Federal Republic has heretofore largely avoided.

Stephen Bannon, President Donald Trump’s most influential and powerful advisor, sees Western civilization locked in an eternal struggle with Islam
Stephen Bannon, President Donald Trump’s most influential and powerful advisor, sees Western civilization locked in an eternal struggle with Islam : Bild: Reuters

In the wake of Trump’s election, much has been said and written about how Germany in general, and Merkel in particular, are now the last remaining guardians of the liberal world order, a sentiment that Senator John McCain appeared to endorse over the weekend at the Munich Security Conference when he praised “the absolutely vital role that Germany and its honorable Chancellor, Chancellor Merkel, are playing in defense of the idea and the conscience of the West” and not so subtly chastised his own president for “flirting with authoritarianism and romanticizing it as our moral equivalent.” Talk of Merkel being “leader of the free world” is rather simplistic and self-flattering; Germany does not possess anything near the military means necessary to assume such responsibility and the scandalous prosecution of a comedian for insulting Turkey’s authoritarian president undermines its commitment to free speech. But in the emerging confrontation between Bannonism and Merkelism that characterizes the struggle for the soul and direction of the Western world, there can be no question of which Weltanschauung must prevail.

James Kirchick is author of The End of Europe: Dictators, Demagogues and the Coming Dark Age, forthcoming from Yale University Press.

Weitere Themen

Macron und Biden vereinbaren „vertiefte Konsultationen“

U-Boot-Streit : Macron und Biden vereinbaren „vertiefte Konsultationen“

Nach dem Zerwürfnis im U-Boot-Streit wollen US-Präsident Biden und Frankreichs Präsident Macron bald zu einem persönlichen Treffen zusammenkommen. In der gemeinsamen Erklärung bestätigte Biden abermals die Bedeutung des französischen Engagements im Indopazifik.


Polizisten am Frankfurter Mainufer.

Was zu tun ist : Den Bürger nicht allein lassen

Der Rechtsstaat sollte konsequent sein: ohne Sicherheit keine Freiheit. Das gilt auch bei der Einwanderungspolitik – die lange von naiven Vorstellungen geleitet wurde.

Zukunft der Schule : „Wir sind total festgefahren“

Dario Schramm ist die Stimme der Schüler in Deutschland. Ein Gespräch darüber, wo es an deutschen Schulen hakt und warum soziale Kompetenzen im Unterricht wieder mehr im Vordergrund stehen sollten.
Besucher in der Temple Bar in Dublin im Juli

Corona in Irland : Impfen für den Pubbesuch

Die Iren haben die höchste Impfquote der EU. Widerstand gegen die Impfungen gibt es kaum. Liegt das an ihrer Liebe zum Feiern? Ein Ortsbesuch in Dublin.
Sitzung des UN-Sicherheitsrats am 16. August 2021

EU-Sitz im Sicherheitsrat : Ein Vorstoß in der „Logik Macrons“?

Ungewöhnlich schnell dementiert Paris die Meldung, Frankreich sei bereit, seinen Sitz im UN-Sicherheitsrat zu teilen. Einzelne glauben jedoch, die Änderung würde zum Präsidenten passen. Auch in Berlin gibt es Sympathien für die Idee


Immer auf dem Laufenden Sie haben Post! Abonnieren Sie unsere FAZ.NET-Newsletter und wir liefern die wichtigsten Nachrichten direkt in Ihre Mailbox. Es ist ein Fehler aufgetreten. Bitte versuchen Sie es erneut.
Vielen Dank für Ihr Interesse an den F.A.Z.-Newslettern. Sie erhalten in wenigen Minuten eine E-Mail, um Ihre Newsletterbestellung zu bestätigen.