Opinion editorial : The Beckenbauer of Global Europe

  • -Aktualisiert am

The Berlin Reichstag is reflected in a car window Bild: dpa

Germany is neither ‘new leader of the free world’ nor ‘captain of the European football team’. The country’s global role can only unfold through Europe.

          I was asked to write about the international role of a 'new Germany'. But what does 'new' mean? Since 1945? Since unification? Since Brexit and the election of Donald Trump led Chancellor Angela Merkel to observe that the times are 'somewhat over' in which Germany could 'fully' rely on others? Or since the German election brought the right-wing populist Alternative für Deutschland (AfD) into the Bundestag, with a shockingly large vote?

          The wise and much missed historian Fritz Stern famously wrote about Five Germanys I Have Known, the Weimar Republic being his first Germany and united Germany, his fifth. We are still in Stern's fifth Germany. There has been no historical caesura since 3 October 1990 large enough to justify talking about a 'new' Germany.

          To consider the international role of the Federal Republic today is therefore to consider a gradual process of growing power and responsibility since 1990, partly as a result of Germany's own policy and intentions, but also because of external developments which Germany did not intend and could only influence to a limited degree. The election of Donald Trump, the Brexit vote and Vladimir Putin's aggression in Ukraine are obvious examples of such developments. But so, less obviously, is the Eurozone. For the great irony of the history of the Eurozone is that a project which was decisively advanced by the French and Italian leaders in 1989/90 in order to bind united Germany more closely into the European Union, and therefore preserve the leadership role of others, has in fact been one of the main forces pushing Germany into its unique leading role in Europe.

          In an essay published in the New York Review of Books in 2013, I formulated the 'new German question' thus: 'can Europe's most powerful country lead the way in building both a sustainable, internationally competitive Eurozone and a strong, internationally credible European Union?' Since then, expectations have soared even higher. It is seriously debated in some quarters whether Chancellor Merkel is now the 'leader of the free world', a suggestion made as early as 2015 by the Die Zeit columnist Jochen Bittner, but more widely discussed since since the Brexit vote and the election of Trump. I even saw an article in the New York Times suggesting she might help to mediate between the USA and North Korea. Like the Chancellor herself, I think this is greatly overdone.

          Germany's global role will emerge above all through Europe, and through Germany's leading role in Europe. This was the conclusion of Frank-Walter Steinmeier's excellent and admirably self-critical 2014 review of German foreign policy, and nothing is likely to change it, at least in the next few years. Hans-Dietrich Genscher once said of German foreign policy 'the more European it is, the more German it is'. Today one might add, 'the more European it is, the more global it is'. The path to a global Germany leads through a global Europe. Of course Germany has its own distinct commercial interests, in China and elsewhere. But only in the wider European framework does that commercial relationship become also a strategic and political asset – or liability.

          Germany cannot demonise Islam at home

          In this context, the familiar observation that the sharp distinction between domestic and foreign policy has increasingly broken down is more true than ever. That is the case, self-evidently, in the linked questions of refugees, immigration, and relations with the Middle East and the world of Islam. Germany cannot demonise Islam at home, in the manner of some AfD leaders, and imagine that has no consequences for its external relations with majority Muslim countries, including Turkey. Those relations in turn have an impact on minorities in Germany. Managing the flow of refugees to Germany involves securing the external border of the whole Schengen area, diplomacy in the wider Middle East and, as Germany's G 20 presidency usefully emphasized, development policy in sub-Saharan Africa.

          Weitere Themen


          Bereits ab 14.00 Uhr könnte die gefühlte Temperatur über 32 Grad liegen, dann herrscht Warnstufe 2. (Archivbild aufgenommen in Berlin)

          Deutscher Wetterdienst : Hitzewarnung für Deutschland

          Der Deutsche Wetterdienst rechnet ab Montag mit ersten Hitzewarnungen. Ab Mittwoch soll dann ganz Deutschland von einer Hitzewelle erfasst werden. Besonders Kinder, alte und kranke Menschen sind durch die hohen Temperaturen gefährdet.


          Immer auf dem Laufenden Sie haben Post! Abonnieren Sie unsere FAZ.NET-Newsletter und wir liefern die wichtigsten Nachrichten direkt in Ihre Mailbox. Es ist ein Fehler aufgetreten. Bitte versuchen Sie es erneut.
          Vielen Dank für Ihr Interesse an den F.A.Z.-Newslettern. Sie erhalten in wenigen Minuten eine E-Mail, um Ihre Newsletterbestellung zu bestätigen.