Committee on Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs : Statement by Christopher Whalen; United States Senate; June 22, 2009

  • Aktualisiert am

„But what makes credit default swaps like betting on the temperature is that, in the case of many if not most of these contracts, the volume of swaps outstanding far exceeds the amount of debt the specified company owes. Most of these swaps therefore have nothing to do with allocating genuine losses of wealth. Instead, they are creating additional losses for whoever bet incorrectly, exactly matched by gains for the corresponding winners. And, ironically, if those firms that bet incorrectly fail to pay what they owe-as would have happened if the government had not bailed out the insurance company AIG-the consequences might impose billions of dollars' worth of economic costs that would not have occurred otherwise.

„This fundamental distinction, between sharing in losses to the economy and simply being on the losing side of a bet, should surely matter for today's immediate question of which insolvent institutions to rescue and which to let fail. The same distinction also has implications for how to reform the regulation of our financial markets once the current crisis is past. For example, there is a clear case for barring institutions that might be eligible for government bailouts-including not just banks but insurance companies like AIG-from making such bets in the future. It is hard to see why they should be able to count on taxpayers' money if they have bet the wrong way. But here as well, no one seems to be paying attention.“

4) CDS & Systemic Risk

While an argument can be made that currency, interest rate and energy swaps are functionally interchangeable with existing forward instruments, the credit derivative market raises a troubling question about whether the activity creates value or helps manage risk on a systemic basis. It is my view and that of many other observers that the CDS market is a type of tax or lottery that actually creates net risk and is thus a drain on the resources of the economic system. Simply stated, CDS and CDO markets currently are parasitic. These market subtract value from the global markets and society by increasing risk and then shifting that bigger risk to the least savvy market participants.

Seen in this context, AIG was the most visible “sucker“ identified by Wall Street, an easy mark that was systematically targeted and drained of capital by JPM, GS and other CDS dealers, in a striking example of predatory behavior. Treasury Secretary Geithner, acting in his previous role of President of the FRBNY, concealed the rape of AIG by the major OTC dealers with a bailout totaling into the hundreds of billions in public funds.

Indeed, it is my view that every day the OTC CDS market is allowed to continue in its current form, systemic risk increases because the activity, on net, consumes value from the overall market - like any zero sum, gaming activity. And for every large, overt failure in the CDS markets such as AIG, there are dozens of lesser losses from OTC derivatives buried by the professional managers of funds and financial institutions in the same way that gamblers hide their bad bets. The only beneficiaries of the current OTC market for derivatives are JPM, GS and the other large OTC dealers.

5) CDS & Securities Fraud

Weitere Themen


Impeachment-Verfahren im Senat : Scheitern mit Ansage

Gut zwölf Stunden dauerte der erste Tag des Prozesses gegen Donald Trump im Senat. Dabei ging es nur um die Verfahrensregeln. Die Demokraten stellten lauter Änderungsanträge. Die Republikaner schmetterten alles ab.
Ein kleiner Schritt für die Menschheit: Mit jedem gestreamten Video vergrößert sich unser ökologischer Fußabdruck.

Klimawandel : Dürfen wir noch streamen?

Jedes Video, das wir online ansehen, schadet dem Klima. Denn die Datenströme verbrauchen große Mengen an Energie. Ist eine Staffel „Game of Thrones“ also so schlimm wie ein Inlandsflug?
Gemütlich zuhause statt in stinkenden Umkleidekabinen – das ist zumindest das Versprechen von Online-Shopping.

Der Moment … : ... in dem ich beschloss, nie mehr online Kleider zu bestellen

Kein Stress mehr vor Ladenschluss, keine Demütigung mehr in der Umkleidekabine: Online-Shopping schien für unsere Autorin himmlisch zu sein. In der Kolumne beschreibt sie den Moment, in dem mit den Paketen dann aber die Hölle bei ihr einzog.


Immer auf dem Laufenden Sie haben Post! Abonnieren Sie unsere FAZ.NET-Newsletter und wir liefern die wichtigsten Nachrichten direkt in Ihre Mailbox. Es ist ein Fehler aufgetreten. Bitte versuchen Sie es erneut.
Vielen Dank für Ihr Interesse an den F.A.Z.-Newslettern. Sie erhalten in wenigen Minuten eine E-Mail, um Ihre Newsletterbestellung zu bestätigen.