Shoshana Zuboff’s Response to Martin Schulz : The New Weapons of Mass Detection

  • -Aktualisiert am

Unternehmer mit staatlichen Aufgaben? Googles Eric Schmidt war auch schon als Minister im Gespräch Bild: AFP

The new military-informational complex: Why politics - not technology - will determine our future. A comment on Martin Schulz.

          16 Min.

          I’ve been holding my breath since the Guardian broke its first Snowden story on June 5, 2013 revealing the NSA’s bulk collection of phone data.  There is a tragic deja vu for me. In 1988, when Google founder Larry Page was fifteen years old and the word “internet” was at least ten years away from public recognition, I published In the Age of the Smart Machine.  The book was based on a decade of fieldwork inside a range of newly computerizing workplaces. During those  years I watched each group succumb to the same pattern. Computer systems that offered rich new learning opportunities at all levels of the firm were  hijacked by a narrow economic model and a managerial ideology of unilateral control.

          (Deutsche Fassung: „Die neuen Massenausforschungswaffen“ von Zshoshana Zuboff)

          Few managers could resist adapting the new systems to a surveillance agenda, as they sought detailed knowledge of workers’ behavior and performance. “The promise of automation,” I wrote seemed to exert a magnetic force, a seduction that promised to fulfill a dream of perfect control and heal egos wounded by their needs for certainty. The dream contains the image of ‘people serving a smart machine,’ but in the shadow of the dream human beings have lost the experience of critical know better than, to question, to say no.” I learned then that only new business models, purposeful leadership, clear strategies, and institutionalized values and practices could alter this course.  Now whole societies are being drawn into the same tragedy.   Technology’s promise of empowerment is under threat from those who seek to dominate through perfect information,  as they grind their way to profit and control.  

          Reading President of the European Parliament Martin Schulz’s message to the German public in his recent FAZ essay, “Warum wir jetzt kämpfen müssen”.  I find myself  exhaling –– at least a little. Schulz writes that the challenge for social democracy in the next century will be to “civilize and humanize” the new technology revolution, while standing fast for the “inviolability of human dignity” in a new world. The challenge I see is that, thanks to Edward Snowden, we know that the technology revolution has once again been hijacked by the dream of perfect control. It’s being used as a  Trojan horse for a still poorly understood convergence of public and private institutions that wield unprecedented power over information. This new power bloc operates outside our control as citizens and consumers.  I’m calling it the military-informational complex, because its  power derives from the production and deployment of what I call new weapons of mass detection composed of information and the technical apparatus required for its access, analysis, and storage.

          We can civilize technology only if we confront this new behemoth. It is this new concentration of power over information, not technology itself,  that drives the “compulsion to control” and the “anti-liberal, anti-social and anti-democratic” dynamisms of which Mr. Schulz writes.  As we have all come to understand, these effects are not limited to any one society. The poison  travels fast and infects the prospects of many societies and the wider civilizational context they share.

          Weitere Themen


          Meteoritenschauer : „Ich hab’ es Feuer regnen sehen“

          Was John Denver 1973 in seinem Lied „Rocky Mountain High“ besungen hat, ist der Höhepunkt des Meteoritenschauers der Perseiden. Jedes Jahr im August kann man nachts bis zu 100 Sternschnuppen pro Stunde sehen.
          Der Kölner Erzbischof Rainer Maria Kardinal Woelki am 31. Mai 2022

          Betroffene im Erzbistum Köln : Von Woelki überrumpelt

          Das Erzbistum Köln bestreitet, dass Kardinal Woelki den Betroffenenbeirat für seine Zwecke instrumentalisiert hat. Recherchen der F.A.Z. stützen diese Darstellung jedoch.


          Immer auf dem Laufenden Sie haben Post! Die wichtigsten Nachrichten direkt in Ihre Mailbox. Sie können bis zu 5 Newsletter gleichzeitig auswählen Es ist ein Fehler aufgetreten. Bitte versuchen Sie es erneut.
          Vielen Dank für Ihr Interesse an den F.A.Z.-Newslettern. Sie erhalten in wenigen Minuten eine E-Mail, um Ihre Newsletterbestellung zu bestätigen.