Federal Elections : Germany’s political consensus cannot last forever

  • -Aktualisiert am

No attack anywhere: federal elections in Germany Bild: Reuters

The world looks upon Germany´s boring election capaign with envy. But that only obscures the many problems of the country. If Germans don´t face them, they will be hit very hard.

          Germans are getting a lot of credit for the dullness of their federal election campaign. This year’s contest is boring by any measure, but in contrast to the ongoing British omnishambles and the second place showing of France’s far right Marine Le Pen – never mind the endless reality show transpiring on the other side of the Atlantic – the competition between Angela Merkel and Martin Schultz is enough to put any drugged-up Berlin hipster to sleep. The willingness to focus on substantive issues and total absence of ad hominem attack, combined with the fact that the two major parties appear to agree more often than not, signifies an admirably „mature“ and „serious“ country. This comity is generally taken to be a good thing. After all, one wouldn’t want German politics to be exciting, right?

          To some extent, this description of the German scene is accurate. Unlike the Brits, who treat politics as the mere continuation of Oxford Union skullduggery and rhetorical showmanship (no more apparent than in the person of Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson), or the grandiloquent French (who, according to the old joke, like to ask, „That works in practice but does it work in theory?“), Germans handle politics with characteristic earnestness.

          Aside from Germans‘ distaste for charismatic politicians, the other major contributor to the country’s current political quietism is consensus, symbolized in the grand coalition government that commands over 500 seats in the Bundestag. Chancellor Merkel, it is often said, has so skillfully occupied the middle ground that she leaves opponents with little material, thus the spectacle of Schultz and SPD Foreign Minister Sigmar Gabriel outdoing each other in saying nice things about the woman they are supposedly trying to unseat from power. While this is an accurate description of her strategy, the nature and durability of Germany’s present political consensus is deceptive. For it is a consensus earned by the country’s unique position as beneficiary of a globalization process now undergoing a series of unexpected reversals.

          Social Democrats are hypocrits

          Post-Cold War globalization has been very good for Germany. Indeed, there is probably no other country in the Western world that has benefitted more from it than the Berlin republic. When the Cold War ended, Germany reunified and once again became the economic (if not political) powerhouse of Europe. Today, Germany is both a security free rider and the main beneficiary of the continental monetary union, two factors that have insulated its domestic politics from the sort of quarrels afflicting its neighbors. 

          Take security. Thanks to its decades-long habitation under the American military umbrella, Germans have dulled themselves into believing that the world is a much safer place than it actually is. In any other country of such size and global importance, the abysmal state of the German armed forces would be a massive scandal and political hot-topic, yet it is barely spoken of in the campaign, and the vast majority of Germans could not care less. Indeed, the SPD is warning against a new „arms race“ with respect to the commitment Nato members made in 2014 to spend 2 percent of their GDP on defense. Even though the Social Democrats are part of the current coalition government that signed this very pledge just three years ago, its association with Donald Trump, who may be the most unpopular American president in Germany since Franklin D. Roosevelt, obscures the party’s hypocrisy.

          Weitere Themen

          Anatomy of a Political Hacking

          EU and Copyright : Anatomy of a Political Hacking

          September, 12th, the European Parliament will vote on a new policy regarding copyright law. MEPs are being bombarded with emails and phone calls – supposedly from worried constituents. A closer look paints a very different picture.

          Dietmar Bartsch ist außer sich Video-Seite öffnen

          Beförderung von Maaßen : Dietmar Bartsch ist außer sich

          Der Linken-Fraktionsvorsitzende Dietmar Bartsch hat die Entscheidung der Koalition im Fall von Verfassungsschutzpräsident Hans-Georg Maaßen heftig kritisiert. Besonders von der SPD ist der Linken-Politiker enttäuscht.


          Pipelines und LNG : Das Erdgas droht Europa zu entzweien

          Amerika wettert weiter gegen die Ostseepipeline Nord Stream 2 – unter Beifall aus Polen. Stattdessen versuchen die Amerikaner, ihr Flüssiggas zu verkaufen. Ist das wirklich eine Alternative oder nur eine große Luftnummer?

          Dialog mit Bürgern in Chemnitz : Der Frust und die Fragen

          Die Chemnitzer Bürgermeisterin sucht nach der Tötung eines Deutschen und den Krawallen in der Stadt den Dialog mit den Bürgern. Doch sie und Sachsens Innenminister Wöller bekommen vor allem eines zu spüren: Unmut.


          Immer auf dem Laufenden Sie haben Post! Abonnieren Sie unsere FAZ.NET-Newsletter und wir liefern die wichtigsten Nachrichten direkt in Ihre Mailbox. Es ist ein Fehler aufgetreten. Bitte versuchen Sie es erneut.
          Vielen Dank für Ihr Interesse an den F.A.Z.-Newslettern. Sie erhalten in wenigen Minuten eine E-Mail, um Ihre Newsletterbestellung zu bestätigen.