Information Consumerism The Price of Hypocrisy

Even the best laws will not lead to a safer internet. We need a sharper picture of the information apocalypse that awaits us in a world where personal data is traded to avert the catastrophy.

© Hackerphotos.com / Win McNamee Dr. Jekyll and Mister Hyde? The military and the IT sphere already affiliated, as you may see in the person of one of the most powerful men of the world: Keith Alexander, Director of the NSA, recruiting hackers at Defcon 2012, wearing a t-shirt of the civil rights organisation „Electronic Frontier Foundation“; in service uniform on the right

The problem with the sick, obsessive superpower revealed to us by Edward Snowden is that it cannot bring itself to utter the one line it absolutely must utter before it can move on: “My name is America and I’m a dataholic.” For American spies, Big Data is like crack cocaine: just a few doses – and you can forget about mending your way and kicking the habit. Yes, there’s an initial illusion of grandeur and narcissistic omnipotence – just look at us, we could prevent another 9/11! – but a clearer, unmediated brain would surely notice that one’s judgment has been severely impaired. Prevent another 9/11? When two kids with extensive presence on social media can blow up a marathon in Boston? Really? All this data, all this sacrifice– and for what?

So let us not pass over America’s surveillance addiction in silence. It is real; it has consequences; and the world would do itself a service by sending America to a Big Data rehab. But there’s more to learn from the Snowden affair. It has also busted a number of myths that are only peripherally related to surveillance: myths about the supposed benefits of decentralized and commercially-operated digital infrastructure, about the current state of technologically-mediated geopolitics, about the existence of a separate realm known as “cyberspace.” We must take stock of where we are and reflect on where we soon will be, especially if we fail to confront – legally but, even more importantly, intellectually – the many temptations of information consumerism.

Why surrender control over electronic communications?

First of all, many Europeans are finally grasping, to their great dismay, that the word “cloud” in “cloud computing” is just a euphemism for “some dark bunker in Idaho or Utah.” Borges, had he lived long enough, would certainly choose a server rack – not a library – as the primary site for his surreal stories. A database larger than the world it is meant to represent: a Borges short story or a slide from an NSA PowerPoint? One can’t say for sure.

Second, ideas that once looked silly suddenly look wise. Just a few months ago, it was customary to make fun of Iranians, Russians and Chinese who, with their automatic distrust of all things American, spoke the bizarre language of “information sovereignty.” What, the Iranians want to build their own national email system to lessen their dependence on Silicon Valley? That prospect seemed both futile and wrong-headed to many Europeans: what a silly waste of resources! How could it possibly compete with Gmail, with its trendy video chats and slick design? Haven’t Europeans tried – and failed – to launch their own search engine? Building airplanes that can compete with Boeing is one thing – but an email system? Now, that’s something Europe – let alone Iran! – would never be able to pull off.

Look who’s laughing now: Iran’s national email system launched a few weeks ago. Granted the Iranians want their own national email system, in part, so that they can shut it down during protests and spy on their own people AT other times. Still, they got the geopolitics exactly right: over-reliance on foreign communications infrastructure is no way to boost one’s sovereignty. If you wouldn’t want another nation to run your postal system, why surrender control over electronic communications?

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 Nächste Seite   |  Artikel auf einer Seite

Hier können Sie die Rechte an diesem Artikel erwerben

Weitere Empfehlungen
Mode-Blog Die Freestylerin

Mit viel Selbstironie hat Leandra Medine ihren Blog The Man Repeller zu einer Instanz in der Modewelt gemacht. Ihre Leserinnen sind jung, emanzipiert und intelligent – wie die Autorin selbst. Mehr Von Claire Beermann

24.09.2015, 21:56 Uhr | Stil
Hörprobe Jaws Shut Like Closing Doors von Disaster In The Universe

Hörprobe: Jaws Shut Like Closing Doors aus dem Album Coconut Message von Disaster In The Universe Mehr

14.09.2015, 15:01 Uhr | Feuilleton
Album der Woche Mit beiden Füßen in Dumbos Straßen

Drogen, Depression: Der amerikanische Nachwuchsrapper Mac Miller hat schwere Zeiten hinter sich. Auf seinem neuen Album GO:OD AM zeigt er sich erholt – aber auch etwas harmlos. Mehr Von Anna Gyapjas

05.10.2015, 17:29 Uhr | Feuilleton
Vernetztes Zuhause Wie gefährlich sind Smart Homes?

Intelligente Häuser nehmen Bewohnern vieles ab. Deshalb werden weltweit immer mehr Smart Homes gebaut. Doch die Technik ist leicht zu überlisten – und somit anfällig für Hackerangriffe. Mehr

30.09.2015, 02:01 Uhr | Technik-Motor
Album der Woche Dem Softeis auf Wiedersehen sagen

Lana Del Rey ist tief aus Oberflächlichkeit. Ihr drittes Album Honeymoon feiert formvollendet die Westküsten-Atmosphäre und überrascht mit lyrischen Zitaten von T. S. Eliot. Mehr Von Dirk von Petersdorff

29.09.2015, 14:59 Uhr | Feuilleton

Veröffentlicht: 24.07.2013, 12:59 Uhr



Von Jürg Altwegg

In einem Film für das Schweizer Fernsehen spart der Schriftsteller Robert Menasse nicht mit Kritik an Alpeneuropa. Kurz vor der geplanten Ausstrahlung wird er abgesetzt. Die Erklärung ist abenteuerlich. Mehr 21 32

Abonnieren Sie den Newsletter „Literatur“